Why You Need an “Otherish” Culture That’s Truly Co-Owned

“If takers are selfish and failed givers are selfless, successful givers are OTHERISH: they care about benefiting others, but they also have ambitious goals for advancing their own interests.” – Adam Grant

Many workplaces default to a tug-of-war between selfless givers and selfish takers, and everyone ends up losing.

Many workplaces default to a tug-of-war between selfless givers and selfish takers, and everyone ends up losing. 

Selfish cultures are ones where people have a “me first” mantra, prioritizing their own needs and goals, while ignoring or sidelining the needs of others. We’ve all seen it:

  • Team members protect their stress levels but rarely offer to lighten the load for someone else.
  • Leaders take all the credit in meetings. 
  • Slack channels become more about showing off than actually collaborating. 
  • Managers push for flexibility when it benefits them, but don’t advocate for their teams. 
  • When mistakes happen, blame gets pushed down instead of shared.

On the flip side, Selfless cultures are ones where people bury their needs and emotions, overextend themselves, neglect their own well-being, and burn out. It’s things like:

  • Emails around the clock that employees are expected to answer
  • People swallow their opinions to keep the peace or avoid backlash.
  • Team members prioritize being liked, putting others’ needs ahead of their own, only to end up drained and resentful. 
  • Leaders praising “above and beyond” while ignoring that it comes at the expense of sleep, sanity, and Saturday mornings with family.

Neither selfish nor selfless leads to sustainable performance, fulfillment, or a healthy environment.

When the pendulum swings between over-giving and hyper-individualism—I’ll take care of me, you take care of you—the result is disconnection, mistrust, and a lack of shared ownership.

The solution isn’t selfishness or selflessness. It’s otherishness: a balance where people honor their own needs and care genuinely about others. It’s not all about me, and it’s not all about you. Sometimes you’ve got to guard your boundaries. Sometimes you lean in and show up for others. Thriving teams happen when we do both.

But here’s the million-dollar question: how the heck do you make that happen?

That’s part of what we help organizations do at Motives Met, take otherish from a nice idea to a real strategic approach, backed by our research. Let’s dive into it. 

What Does “Otherish” Mean?

This concept comes from Adam Grant, organizational psychologist, Wharton professor, and best-selling author of many books, including “Give and Take: A Revolutionary Approach to Success.” 

He says, “If takers are selfish and failed givers are selfless, successful givers are

OTHERISH: They care about benefiting others, but they also have ambitious goals for

advancing their own interests.”

  • Takers put their own interests first, often at the expense of others.
  • Selfless givers put others’ needs first, often at their own expense.
  • Otherish givers succeed by balancing both: they’re generous but also mindful of their own well-being.

Otherish individuals don’t burn out because they honor their needs, speak up, ask for support, protect their boundaries, and actually say no when they need to. Yet they don’t ignore the needs of others because they have compassion and are invested in everyone’s well-being and success. To them, winning isn’t “me over you” or “you over me.” It’s we all win, together. It’s not just their success, but collective success, not just their health, but the team’s health. 

Imagine an entire workplace operating that way, that’s a culture people want to be part of.

Otherish at the Culture Level

Otherish is a culture strategy built for the future of work, one that puts the 28 human needs, or motives, that drive health, happiness, and high-performance in our work lives and workplaces front and center.

Here’s the tough truth: motives don’t matter equally to each person or team, we all have some motives that rise to the top and others we honestly just don’t value as much or need in the way others do. That makes being otherish challenging, because it’s easy to ignore, judge, or dismiss motives that don’t drive us in the same way.

  • I may fulfill my need for purpose outside of work, and for someone else, purpose is a must-have motive to be well and perform well. 
  • I might be motivated by security, while my teammate is driven by innovation; motives can hold tension, and that tension shows up big time in our relationships. 
  • As leaders, we may prioritize our autonomy but overlook others’ need for connection.

On the flip side, we may care too much about the organization or other people’s top motive priorities, we may overextend ourselves chasing achievement, innovation, or recognition, burning out in the process. 

An otherish culture is one where people embrace motive diversity, care deeply about others, and honor their own driving motives at the same time.

For example:

WORK LIFE – HARMONY Motive → It’s saying no to extra work to protect your work-life harmony and sometimes saying yes to additional hours to help a team member who is too buried to help them protect theirs. 

CONNECTION Motive → It’s knowing some team members are fueled by connection and saying yes to the invite to grab lunch (even if you may have preferred to eat solo) or join the team happy hour from time to time, while also trusting they respect that all the work social events may not be your thing, and you will opt out of some of them.

CLEAR EXPECTATIONS Motive → It’s asking for clear expectations and structure because that’s how you do your best work, while also giving grace to the teammate who thrives with autonomy and fewer guardrails.

FAIRNESS Motive → It’s not fighting every battle that isn’t yours, but when you see something unjust or harmful, you step in and speak up, because someone else’s dignity matters too.

APPRECIATION Motive → It’s recognizing that appreciation isn’t high on your motive hierarchy and doesn’t come as naturally to you. But making the effort to pause and express gratitude because even if it’s not what fuels you, it can be what makes someone else feel truly valued.

Co-Creating a Thriving Culture with a Motives Mindset

Otherish cultures are built on a shared belief system:

  • Everyone deserves healthy motives at work. I don’t have to be best friends with you, and heck let’s be real, I might not like you, but I do need to believe that everyone deserves their motives to be healthy. That I don’t need to be the reason someone feels they don’t belong, to stunt their growth or silence their voice.

     

  • Give and take are inseparable. Healthy relationships depend on reciprocity. Giving and receiving are both essential rhythms; everyone has to contribute, and everyone has to feel supported. When either side is missing, the balance breaks down.

     

  • There are no favorites. We have to respect motive diversity; my top needs aren’t better or more important than yours, they’re just different. We all have different ways of working, motivational triggers, and perspectives that are driven by the diversity of our needs. Thriving cultures honor that difference instead of dismissing it.
  • Culture belongs to everyone. It isn’t handed down by leaders or carried alone by HR. It’s co-created, moment by moment, motive by motive, by every member of the team. My motives and yours are interconnected. You could put any motive in the middle of this diagram, whether it’s fun, free expression, or future success, and the degree it will be met will be impacted by everyone. 

 

Adopting the Motives Mindset sparks a collective commitment, an otherish way of showing up that empowers people to co-own and actively shape the culture.

Putting It Into Action

  1. Cultivate the Motives Mindset.

Share the 28 human motives so everyone has a common language and understanding for what truly drives well-being and success in our work lives and workplaces. This turns the vague idea of ‘thriving at work’ into a unified goal, building a culture where motives are strong. It shifts conversations, builds empathy, and lays the foundation for healthier, more human workplaces.

2. Get curious about what matters most.

Empower employees, teams, and leaders to know and talk about their top motives, which makes work relationships stronger and an otherish culture becomes possible.

The key is to know what drives each person, to notice the differences and work through tension points, and have real conversations about motive strengths and weaknesses.

That’s why we created the Motives Met Human Needs Assessment™, to give you the clarity, language, and insights to make those conversations meaningful and actionable.

3. Build accountability into the culture.

It’s not enough to know each other’s motives; people need to act on them. Hold people accountable for being otherish, honoring both their own needs and the needs of others. When someone undermines a motive, address it; if they consistently harm motives? Show them the door. When they strengthen motives, recognize it, and make that recognition matter, all the way up to promotion decisions.

A Culture of Successful Givers

An otherish culture sets a new standard: sustainable generosity. Where giving doesn’t deplete, it energizes, because motives are being met on all sides. 

 

WORK LIFE
WELL-LIVED

Join the Community

Motives Toolbox

Motives Met Human Needs Assessment

Motive Team Experiences

Motives for Leaders

Most Viewed Articles

Work Armor ≠ Professionalism: Making Work Feel Human

“Having needs is not evidence of weakness - it is human.” I love this quote by Danielle Bernock because the employee experience is a critical extension of the human experience. So many of us have been taught the lie that professionalism=dehumanization, that we need to...

Meaningful Questions About What Matters Most to Ask Your Employees

I had so much fun speaking and leading a workshop around well-being and culture with the amazing leaders and Inner Fifth Members founded by Tracy Holland. One part of the session members told me they found especially inspiring and informative was around the power of...

The 15% White Space Rule for Work-Life Harmony

“Give it your all.” We’ve all heard this mantra, whether from motivational speakers or well-meaning mentors. But here's the truth bomb: we're not built to operate at 110% all the time. Heck, we're not even meant to function at a constant 100%. Trying to hit that...